Deep Purple studio albums ranked

Let’s sort this one out! White I expect certain albums to surface at the top and bottom, there will probably be those that end up at both ends, and some will remain squarely in the middle… anyway, here’s my nowadays trendy tier list. If you are not familiar with the concept, S equals a superior album, A is an excellent one, B is a good record and C is an average, D below-average with redeeming qualities and F just not worth the time. I have tried to use an even distribution and these are ranked in relation to each other - in terms of music in general, even on a bad day, Deep Purple are above average.

S - Machine Head, In Rock, Burn

A - Fireball, Perfect Strangers

B - Shades Of Deep Purple, Come Taste The Band, Bananas, Abandon, Purpendicular, The House of Blue Light

C - Stormbringer, Who Do We Think We Are, Rapture of the Deep, Now What ?!, Infinite, Deep Purple, Book of Taliesyn

D - The Battle Rages On, Slaves and Masters, Splat, Whoosh, =1

F - Turning to Crime

It is telling that if I should pick my top 25 or something Purple tracks, several of them would be from albums on the lower end of the scale - they are just not as good taken as a whole.

Of the albums, I am willing to still give Splat the benefit of doubt, and I might or not move it up a notch in the coming years. In general I don’t really see myself listening to their 2020’s albums over and over if given the choice of picking anything from the discography. And I must say I enjoy listening to S&M and even TBRO, even if I recognize they feel “forced”.

Anyway, waiting for counterarguments and all the silliness involved in arguing matters of taste, show your lists!

1 Like

Ah - the impossible question. Wars have been lost over less.

But I’m a Gillan fan, so

  1. Anything with Gillan

  2. Everything else

  3. Slaves & Masters

:wink:

3 Likes

To me it is:

In Rock
Machine Head
Made in Japan
Fireball
Who do we think we are
Perfect Strangers
The Battle rages on
House of blue light

And then the rest is almost on the same place…
I liked very much when RB was a part of Purple. Yeah, Ian as the singer and Ritchie as the guitarist just makes my little motor running.
Since I got to know this site (or the original HS) I have come to appreciate Burn a lot too.

1 Like
  1. Absolutely vital:

    Machine Head

    Burn

    Come Taste The Band

  2. Worthy releases:

    The Book Of Taliesyn

    Fireball

    Perfect Strangers (but just ever so barely, in danger of slipping to category 5 :down_arrow:)

    Purpendicular

    Abandon

    Bananas

    Now What!

    Whoosh!

    =1

    SPLAT!

  3. A lot better than their reputation:

    Who Do We Think We Are

    Stormbringer

    The House Of Blue Light

    Slaves & Masters

  4. Musically overrated, but of great historical significance:

    In Rock (but approaching category 2 :up_arrow:)

  5. Yeah, ok, but nothing to write home about:

    “April” (aka third album)

    Rapture Of The Deep

    Infinite

  6. A bit naff:

    Shades Of

    Turning To Crime

  7. What a load of undiluted crap:

    The Battle Rages On

1 Like

File under male chauvinistic disparaging remarks:

If her list is to be believed, then Karin thinks Made in Japan is a studio album. Go tell everyone else! :smiling_face_with_horns:

1 Like

Except for when I was ever so young and being introduced to the band, I don’t listen to different lineups concurrently. Also back in the day (late 70’s or early 80’s), I would be jumping around different Marks to show someone else the difference etc. So it really depends on the mood at the time with me, when I listen to Mark I songs, that is what I am interested in at that time, the same with other lineups. Some albums stand alone, CTTB and Deep Rainbow. So here we go, Book of Taliesyn, then ‘April’ and Shades. In Rock, Fireball, MH and WDWTWA (1970’s mood). Burn then Stormbringer. Reunion: THOBL, TBRO then PS. Then Purpendicular, Now What, Whoosh and then it is really difficult as those other albums are incredibly boring to me. At the moment with McBride era, = 1 then Splat. The Concerto from 1969 also stands alone, being an orchestral album as such. Have I left any albums out? Don’t mention the covers album. Cheers.

1 Like

Oh you! :rofl::rofl:
I never said Made in Japan is a studio album.
I ranked them after how important they are to me.
(Whoops didn’t se the headline mentioned studio albums :face_with_hand_over_mouth:)

Well never mind, Made in Japan is the most important live album I have ever beard!
Ok?
Ok!

I am starting to second guess my choices… i mean, a case could be made for Slaves and Masters that it is, in fact, the missing Rainbow album between Bent and Stranger, where Lord takes over from Rosenthal and Paicey from Burgi… and all of a sudden it becomes a lot better record. :wink:

1 Like

Never argue with a woman.

I rest my case.

1 Like

Now there was a reason for the formulation I chose - ranking Deep Purple live albums (all 666 and counting) would be a Herculean task for even the most dedicated. My personal favourites are Nobody’s Perfect and On the Wings of a Russian Foxbat (both of which I actually listen to more than Made in Japan, while there is of course no contest).

1 Like

There is a lot of good stuff, MiJ, Mk IV Long Beach and even Budokan, MK III Live in London, Mk VII Olympia …

666 ???Oh no! Are you sure it is THAT number? That is a worry…

1 Like

I guess Edith will thank me in due time….

Yes I know, but listen here: I just woke up, saw this post, grabbed my pen (figuratively speaking) and wrote…
Later on, when Uwe criticised me, as he always does, I saw the headline :grinning_face_with_smiling_eyes:
Now I have had several cups of coffee, I can think again to some extent :face_with_monocle:

I promise to be more attentive in the future….

1 Like

Yes as we ALL know Karin, the man with many words is ALWAYS watching and waiting, he he he. I am going to change the epitaph on his tombstone to read 'Here lies the Man with many words, and isn’t it nice and quiet at this moment". Ha ha ha ha. I cannot wait, he he he. I wonder if Uwe’s family will let me be pallbearer? I can only hope. Cheers.

2 Likes

Don’t feel too bad Karin, I even mentioned a ‘live’ album, the Concerto from 1969. Mind you, I haven’t been dragged over the coals as yet for that, time will tell. Cheers.

1 Like

To be honest, and please don’t tell this to Uwe MacGregor: I hope he dies after I’m gone :pleading_face: because he is so funny and my kind of big bro, but don’t let him know - his head is big enough as it is :grin:

You know what? Your secret is safe with me :smiley:

But I never really criticize you, Karin, it’s just my hapless way of trying to attract your attention while you prefer flirting with that Tasmanian schoolyard bully!

https://youtu.be/waQtbweHNmg

1 Like

I live by two rules in my life Uwe:

  1. I drink a lot of coffee :heart_eyes:
  2. I never flirt
    and 3), oh wait I live by three rules in my life:
  • the coffee thing
  • the no flirt thing
  • I am always honest
    And 4) - oh wait I live by four rules in my life:
  1. coffee… a plenty
  2. no flirt… never do
  3. honesty in all situations…
  4. I’m eagerly awaiting the Spanish Inquisition :rofl:
1 Like